Research investigation

Explore how women are represented in the TV shows EastEnders and Hollyoaks

 

EastEnders is a British soap opera that has been broadcasted on BBC One since 1985,which was created by Julia smith and Tony Holland. Since The creation of EastEnders there have been thousands of storylines highlighting various different issues that happen in day-to-day life. Hollyoaks is also another soap opera that was broadcasted on channel 4 in 1995 that was created by Phil Redmond. 

I have decided to conduct my research on how women are represented in the TV shows Hollyoaks and EastEndersbecause I think that the way women are shown in soap operas is very stereotypical

There are a numerous amounts of representations of women in these two TV shows, which are mostly the stereotypes of women yet there are a still a few positive representations. The stereotypes are often things such as “women are weak”, “all women are housewives”, and “women are only good for one thing". In Hollyoaks we see a fictional character calledMaxine Minniver played by (Nikki Sanderson) being abused by her fiancé Patrick Blake (Jeremy Sheffield). During this storyline Maxine made numerous attempts to leave her fiancé but decided to stay with him because despite everything she “loved him”. The storyline portrays women as vulnerable, easy and stupid. Women are seen as so desperate for attention and for someone to love them that they become susceptible to anything because as said by the brainwashed society women are “mentally and physically weak”.

However in EastEnders we see female characters trying hard not to be the “typical” women that the society has branded women as, an example of this is when Fictional character Denise fox played by (Diane Parish) decides that she wants to sit her GCSE English at the age of 48, and despite many people making jokes about her sitting a GCSEs she didn’t let that discourage her and she went on to passing. This represents women as strong, determined individuals who don’t need help from anyone, and it also shows that women are strong independent women who don’t need a man to tell them that they are good enough. 

The usual stereotype that women are weak is shown in an episode where character Phil Mitchellplayed by (Steven McFadden)races to find his daughter Louise Mitchell played by (Tilly keeper) after she had been taken from the hospital by her unstable mum Lisa Fowler played by (Lucy Benjamin) who is known for her mental illness. The scene shows Phil Mitchell burst into the hotel room that Louise and Lisa had been staying. Tensions rise high when Louise becomes unresponsive and out of anger Phil shouts out “You stupid weak pathetic woman” at a vulnerable Lisa who he can clearly see erratically shaking and crying. The position of the camera shows Phil on the floor and Lisa standing up, theoretically Lisa is supposed to have the most power because she is standing however in this case she is portrayed as a weak women whereas Phil seems to have more authority even though he has a lower status.

In the Two soapswomen often play subordinate roles compared to men for example in Hollyoaks and EastEnders we see women play typical motherly house wife roles. Character Zainab Masood is traditional housewife that most people expect everyone to be. Zainab is also a well put together women who looks after her household and her children, which shows that she is caring and would go above and beyond for her children.

Hollyoaks Character Goldie McQueen is not the typical stay at home mum that every mother is suspected to be. The character Goldie is represented as a loud mouth red head that thrives off attention but besides from that she tries to be the best mother she can. The representation of this female character is quite negative because the soap kind of reinforces the stereotype that all women do is go around drinking, smoking and sleeping with random men. Hollyoaks often show characters like Goldie as good for nothing home wreckers. Also most of the young women are often sexualized, and they’re looked upon as trash and damaged goods.

During my research I discovered that the majority of women in soap operas have mental illnesses and just a few men have a mental illness, this research shows that women are supposedly weaker than men. The examples of the characters with mental illness are Stacey fowler who has bipolar disorder, which her mother Jean slater also has. According to mental health foundation In “’England, women are more likely than men to have a common mental health problem1and are almost twice as likely to be diagnosed with anxiety disorders.2         

Some other facts that I found out from the mental health foundation:

▪ In 2013, 6,233 suicides were recorded in the UK for people aged 15 and older. Of these, 78%were male and 22% were female.3

▪ 10% of mothers and 6% of fathers in the UK have mental health problems at any given time.4

▪ One in five (19.1%) women had CMD symptoms, compared with one in eight men (12.2%). 5

In contrast to women the representation of men is not that bad compared to women, but most men are shown as hardworking businessmen for example character Phil Mitchell is shown as this big important man that provides for his family and also jack branning is another key example of a typical businessman yet there seem to be any female business women in EastEnders however there are some business women in Hollyoaks such as grace black that challenges the stereotypes. According to The Masculinity and Popular Television Book “men are socialized to be ambitious competitors estranged from their fellings. Also stated that ‘’ men and women possess interchangeable emotional, intellectual and psychological traits, so that any conversational differences between the two is simply a matter or sex role stereotyping and cultural conditioning.”

In conclusion to my initial research I found that women in soap operas in general are shown really in a negative light. Referring to the hypodermic needle a lot of people that watch these shows are influenced in such a way that it makes them believe what they see on TV as true which gives women a bad image.